Best Ice Cream, Winner Cold Stone Creamery Address: 291 PiĎikea Ave. # 121, Kihei, HI 96753 Phone: 808-875-8811 Website: http://www.coldstonecreamery.com Like some politicians, I sometimes pay for pleasure. However, my self indulgence consists of mainly tipping teenagers so they grudgingly sing me reworked versions of show tunes while they mash choice toppings like fudge, strawberries and M&Ms into Cold Stoneís house-made ice creams. I guess Maui Time readers go for this kind of stuff too, since Cold Stone took it away at the polls for Best Ice Cream. I donít need to tell you that some politicians should follow our lead. Ice cream at Cold Stone is pure creamy deliciousness. Not only will the servers serenade you, they serve up some of the most delicious ice cream concoctions designed by none other than yourself. You donít even have to pay extra for that. Located island-wide.