SHARE
flag
the grid

Maui County


Busted!


One Maui resident feels the sting of the state's tough new criminal speeding law



MAUICOUNTY
shadow
photo: Ray Mangan.
December 06, 2007
Every so often we all find ourselves driving a little too fast. Perhaps we’re in a bit of a hurry, late for an appointment, or passing a shiny new Chrysler Sebring on the Pi‘ilani carrying occupants more concerned with the scenery than the cars around them.

Laura Kaplan, a 42-year-old massage therapist from Kihei, was in just one of those situations last May when she was nabbed by a Maui Police speed trap. Clocked at traveling 77 mph between North Kihei Road and Ma‘alaea, Kaplan thought she was in for a citation and perhaps a stiff fine. But because she was going more than 30 mph over the posted limit, she actually faced much worse.

Last year the state pushed through a tough new speeding law aimed at curbing traffic fatalities. When Kaplan showed up for court the following month, she had no idea what she was in for.

“Only when I spoke to the public defender did the enormity of this ticket hit me like a ton of bricks,” she said. “I realized I was in a different ballgame. I was not in traffic court, I was in criminal court.”

Kaplan stood before Judge Sydney Pollak. She sentenced her to two days in jail. Citing prior speed infractions—one in 2004 and another in 1995—Pollak didn’t offer Kaplan community service, an option available to those with no priors.

“This is a freaking nightmare and no one I speak to has even heard of this law,” Kaplan said.

According to Hawai‘i Statute 291C-105, a first offender caught going 30 miles per hour over the posted limit or 80 mph anywhere will be subject to the following:

• A fine of between $500 and $1,000;

• 30-day suspension of a driver’s license;

• A driver retraining course;

• A surcharge of $25 to be deposited into a neurotrauma special fund.

Oh, and either 36 hours of community service or two to five days of imprisonment.

Lt. Bobbie Hill, director of Maui PD’s traffic division, said the tougher penalties are in response to a rash of speed related fatalities across the state over the past year.

“From this Mother’s Day [a month before he took over the traffic division] till now we’re averaging one fatality a week,” Hill said. “It’s a matter of thinking about what you’re doing, there’s no real need to go that fast. These laws actually have teeth now. People need to realize, you can go to jail.”

Kaplan served her jail sentence last month and found it less than accommodating.

“I was forced to spend 48 hours in a prison lock-up with long-term inmates, made to sleep on a concrete floor in a cell with two other women who lived there,” she said. “Locked away 19 hours a day and made to pick bugs out of my food. How is this supposed to make me stop speeding?”

Kaplan said her troubles are just beginning. She was assessed a $600 fine and lost her license for a month—no small penalty for someone who drives all over the island for work. She must also now file an SR-22 form with her insurance company, which will undoubtedly raise her premiums.

“In the end, after all that has happened to me, I wish I could tell the world I’ve learned my lesson: I no longer speed,” she said. “But I can’t. I am an assertive, safe driver. I get to where I am going and pay attention, but you know, I still speed. Maybe I won’t go over 30 consciously, but yup, I speed. Everyone else does, too.” MTW

print
Print
email
Email Link
Comment
Feedback
share
Share
  1. print email
    geez...
    December 06, 2007 | 09:42 PM

    that sucks, but 30 mph over the speed limit c'mon wha'd you think was gonna happen. you in one hurry, try go early

    cautious driver
  2. print email
    Alert!
    December 07, 2007 | 12:40 PM

    Didn't the Maui Police department publish over a month ago that they are doing a campaign to bust ALL drivers traveling more than the POSTED speed limit? People ASSUME they can drive 10 or even miles over the limit and be okay. Or just because others are riding your ass you are okay "going with the flow". I am sure MPD published the fact that they are likely to ticket anyone... so WTF would one think 30 over, even on a "deserted" stretch, is not a prosecutable crime. I didn't know about the new law, but since I regard posted limits I really don't even need to know about it. Gotcha! DAAAamn. If it is NECESSARY to be rushing around, working several jobs, just to make ends meet, there is something very wrong with this picture that needs to be addressed... now, rather than later. And she states that she is still going to speed. As the locals say... S.F.H.

    Molokai Guy
  3. print email
    Sympathy? I don't think so!
    December 07, 2007 | 07:55 PM

    Was this article supposed to evoke sympathy for a stupid driver who can't keep it in her head that speed kills? Puhleeze! You deserve every minute you got in jail.

    How do you think she was driving 77 on a mostly crowded highway anyway? Weaving in and out recklessly I'm sure. S.F.H. is right!

    Never.Been.Ticketed
  4. print email
    everyone speeds? just so you know, i don't!
    December 08, 2007 | 03:37 AM

    but, here's my favorite quote:

    “I was forced to spend 48 hours in a prison lock-up with long-term inmates, made to sleep on a concrete floor in a cell with two other women who lived there,” she said. “Locked away 19 hours a day and made to pick bugs out of my food. How is this supposed to make me stop speeding?”

    not only does she not understand that speeding is dangerous and not appropriate behavior, i am not sure she understands that she might be risking incarceration-- even after she's spent a few nights in the gray bar hotel with her new best friends... she still plans on speeding? um... arrogant? cavalier? SFH

    Jake Blues
  5. print email
    Waaah!
    December 09, 2007 | 01:20 AM

    As Janis would say, Cry baby! I had 2 nites in M3C for punching my boyfriend, could have been more. Think I'm gonna do it again? No way, Jose!

    Been there
  6. print email
    I'm a Family Guy.
    December 09, 2007 | 02:47 PM

    As such, I have no sympathy for anyone (espcially a 42 yr old) who could potentially put MY family at risk. If you had to drive 30 miles an hour over the posted limit to PASS, how fast was the person in front of you going? Nice choice of journalism Jared Libby. Tool.

    Grayson S Lahaina, Maui
  7. print email
    Some family guy...
    December 09, 2007 | 07:18 PM

    What are you going after Libby for? He's a reporter who did his job by writing a story about a woman who went to jail for speeding. If the story made you mad, then I'd say Libby did his job. Jerk.

    John P, Wailuku
  8. print email
    BackAssWard
    December 12, 2007 | 12:39 PM

    Another case of Hawaii's assbackward laws. Lets allow Ice to continue to distory our state and lock up people who speed.

    Lets arrest home owners for renting their homes and ignore the truancy and petty crimes. You get more time for speeding than a DUI ! That makes a lot of sense.



    Koa
  9. print email
    S.F.H.
    December 14, 2007 | 12:41 PM

    S.F.H..
    Does that apply to angry MOKES in monster trucks ?
    or
    Iced out FLIPS raceing to get nowhere ?
    Is it rue that coconuts are brown on the outside and white on the inside ?
    JUST FOR THE RECORD .
    JUST TO GET THIS STRAIGHT .
    THE ONLY PEOPLE IN LOCK UP ARE BROWN AND POOR !
    WHAT DOES THAT TELL YOU ABOUT THE JUSTICE ?SYSTEM !!!!


    Poor judgment
  10. print email
    Apology
    December 14, 2007 | 12:56 PM

    Bigotry is ugly,distastful and dehumanizeing......
    If your people have been persecuted then you understand.
    I am sorry for hurting anyone with my hard words.
    I was wrong.
    Those terms need never be used again.



    poor judgment
Reader Feedback Submission
Use this form to submit Reader Feedback.
* required value
Your Name*

Town

Email (not shown on website)

Subject

Comment*

Verification*


Calendar Search
Event
calendar icon
Zip Code Proximity
of
Entertainment and lifestyle news for Maui, Hawaii and the surrounding Islands. Maui Time Weekly is Mauis only independent and locally owned newspaper. Mail this link to a friend
Web Analytics