SHARE
flag
the grid

In the Name of the 'Father,' part 2



LEDE_3
shadow
Tractors on Evangelista's farm
February 28, 2008
Patricia Bragg often drops the the name Paul C. Bragg, a famous California nutritionist and lecturer from the early and mid-20th century. There's a picture of the two prominently placed on her company's website (www.bragg.com). His name also appears on every product and book put out by Bragg Live Food Products.

She must have used the words "my dad" in reference to the late nutritionist and 1920's Los Angeles Times health food columnist Paul Bragg at least a dozen times during the course of our Feb. 15 interview. But he was not her biological father.

According to her California birth certificate, she was born Patricia Pendleton at Oakland's Peralta Hospital. Her birth took place at 1:57 a.m. on April 29, 1929, and her biological parents were Harry C. and Nettie Pendleton.

Harry Pendleton's 1961 obituary noted that he was a well-known San Francisco land developer and former Little Rock newspaper reporter who was "the first to send a telegram to the rest of the United States after the earthquake of 1906." Nettie's obit listed her as a "fourth-generation Californian."

shadow
shadow
Patricia's use of the Bragg name comes from her marriage to Robert E. Bragg, a chiropractor and son of Paul Bragg. That makes Paul Bragg Patricia's father-in-law.

Maui Time could find no record of when that marriage took place. But their 1956 divorce proceedings were apparently such big news that the Los Angeles Times covered it. On Jan. 17, 1956, the Times even quoted Patricia as saying that she and Paul were very close.

"He treats me just like his very own daughter and I'm so thankful," she said in the Times story, which included a photo of a smiling Patricia and Paul shaking hands with a not-really smiling Robert in the courtroom. "And I treat him like my very own father. I feel very obligated to him."

It's unknown what Harry Pendleton, who was still alive in 1956, thought of those words.

Already familiar with the Times' coverage when Patricia visited my office, I asked her if, in fact, Paul was actually her father-in-law. "Yes," she said, "but he adopted me."

"He adopted you?" I asked, remembering that Patricia was 26 at the time of her divorce from Robert Bragg. "He legally adopted you?"

"Yes," she said. "He legally adopted me."

While certainly possible—adult adoptions are legal in California—Maui Time could find no public record of it having taken place. When I asked Patricia when the adoption occurred, she said simply, "Years and years ago. My private life is my private life."

This became a nearly constant refrain. "You don't need to go into that," she'd lecture me whenever I asked about her biological parents. "I'm not a Hollywood celebrity."

Later, she finally agreed to speak briefly about them.

"I had a wonderful mother," Patricia said. "I was very blessed. Both my dads got along—they were like brothers. I've been very blessed."

Patricia added that Paul Bragg "was like a father to me from the day I was born. He stayed in our house many times. It was programmed for me to marry his son. But it just didn't work out."

* * *

Bragg.com lists many, many accomplishments for Patricia Bragg, but one in particular stands out: that she's "the youngest woman ever to be granted a U.S. Patent." We couldn't confirm that, but Bragg is indeed an inventor.

On Oct. 29, 1957, the U.S. Patent office approved invention Number 2,811,156. It's for a "Douche or Enema Device" that can be "arranged or mounted between a water supply source and an injection discharge nozzle."

"It was really fascinating," Bragg told me of the events surrounding her patent approval. "We went to Washington, D.C. The head of the Patent Office gave us a personal tour."

The name on the patent is Patricia Pendleton Bragg, though it appears she stopped using her maiden name not long after that, becoming just Patricia Bragg. That people might think Patricia was actually Paul Bragg's biological daughter didn't seem to bother her—"There's no reason they'd be confused," she told me. In fact, there's some evidence that Patricia doesn't mind it when people believe that Paul Bragg was her biological father.

Near the end of our Feb. 15 interview, Patricia gave me a brochure titled "Patricia Bragg, born to carry on her father's health crusade." It was labeled a "reprint" of a long article from Natural Foods Merchandiser, a health foods industry trade publication. I put the word "reprint" in quotes because the brochure Bragg handed me is very different from the story as published by NFM.

Originally titled "Patricia Bragg: born to do her father's work," the NFM story was written by a Colorado freelance writer and editor named Vicky Uhland, whose name appears nowhere on the Bragg brochure. Uhland's story contained numerous details and quotes not found in the brochure Patricia Bragg handed me.

For example, Uhland's story contains the following sentences: "Paul C. Bragg was born in 1880, 1881 or 1895, depending on who you believe. Some Internet sites have posted a Social Security death index entry for a Paul Bragg of Desert Hot Springs, Calif., (where Paul C. Bragg lived) who was born in February 1895 and died in December 1976."

Those sentences are nowhere to be found in Bragg's brochure, which also appears on the Bragg company website. At one point in her story, Uhland quotes Paul Wenner as saying, "Patricia's a wonderful mystery, like a little medicinal butterfly going from flower to flower." But in Bragg's brochure, the quote is very different: "Patricia's a gifted crusader, like a little medicinal butterfly going from flower to flower."

Reached by phone, Uhland said she was aware that Bragg's reprint was very different from her version.

"The article on the [Bragg*] website has been changed from what I wrote," Uhland told me. "I later found out that she's not his daughter."

Uhland was referring to the following characterization she made early in her story: "Not only was Paul Bragg responsible for his daughter's physical existence, he also shaped her emotional, spiritual and mental character."

Bragg apparently had no problem with that obviously incorrect statement, because it appears word-for-word in her reprint.

* The article originally misidentified the website containing Uhland's modified story

PART 3: Bragg and religion ->

In the Name of the 'Father' - Part 1 | Part 2 | Part 3
print
Print
email
Email Link
Comment
Feedback
share
Share
  1. print email
    Fox Noise
    March 01, 2008 | 11:18 PM

    Congradulations Anthony. Your hatchet job on this woman may land you a job on FOX. Hope you move soon.

    Not Your Fan
  2. print email
    "Fool Me Once, Shame On You;
    March 02, 2008 | 11:42 AM

    ool Me Twice, Shame on Me!"

    Sounds like an excellent old adage to always remember re either or both Braggs to me.

    Thanks. Very good & balanced article.

    A Reader
  3. print email
    A. Pignatero's school grades??
    March 03, 2008 | 02:21 PM

    You raise a cloud of dust about her intentions, but when it all settles, there is nothing to really grab ahold of and chew. More power to her and I hope no one finds out what your grades in journalism school REALLY were. I mean, if they ever found out the truth about you, .. well... you will see! Get my drift?

    Bill
  4. print email
    Sorry Bill, but school grades...
    March 03, 2008 | 03:29 PM

    are really immaterial here...good, bad or indifferent...unless you LIE about them (as Patricia did about her "real" father). And claimed then she had never married---I guess ex-husbands don't count? (see "Born To Do Her Father's Work"...the original or the Bragg revised version---take your choice).

    Get my drift??

    A Reader
  5. print email
    Grades redux
    March 04, 2008 | 11:15 AM

    My previous comment was to point out that this article, IMO, may be classified as yellow journalism due to it's scandalmongering style. Nothing heavy or noteworthy was written about her intentions for the land. Her explainations for the parcel applications appears to be valid, going up against a bureaucracy without having all your ducks in a row is never a good idea. She recognized that and did not finalize giving the parcel to the tenant farmers as agreed until the "i" were dotted. Good thinking on her part.
    My attrib to the school grades was to point out that the story is not as it was painted by the author, you can't raise issues when they have nothing backing them up. I am sure Mr. Pignatero was a FINE student and deserved any grade he received. That was not the point. It was to point out that he devolved the article into something just this side of libel. OK, she lied about her past. What has that got to do with what is going on now? She has dealt with her tenant farmers fairly. NUFF SAID!

    Bill
  6. print email
    Bragg is a Public Figure
    March 04, 2008 | 04:12 PM

    Bragg's real estate holdings on Maui certainly qualify her as a public figure. The simple fact that Bragg ASKED to be interviewed solidifies her status as a public figure. Pignataro used a combination of public documents and personal interviews to highlight numerous inconsistencies in a public figure's personal and business history. Pignataro's work is called journalism, folks. We don't see much journalism these days, and those among us who do not recognize bonafide journalism are paying too much attention to the fearmongers in the media. Kudos to Pignataro. Long may he reign on Maui!

    Tony
  7. print email
    I don't see Patricia...
    March 04, 2008 | 04:41 PM

    "giving" her tenant farmers anything. There's mention of setting aside 10 acre parcels for organic farming & that a couple of individuals "purchased" some acreage that has not yet been transferred to them. But currently all I see for her tenant farmers are "monthly" leases. How is that different from a 30-day rental?

    Did I miss something Bill?

    A Reader
  8. print email
    Can't we all just get along?
    March 06, 2008 | 10:13 AM

    A Reader: Nobody's perfect. (including you, me, Patricia Bragg and Anthony Pignatero) ALOHA is what MauiTime should be practicing, not innuendo. Good reporting? OK, sounds good. Picking fights with others? Nope, not a good thing.

    Bill
Reader Feedback Submission
Use this form to submit Reader Feedback.
* required value
Your Name*

Town

Email (not shown on website)

Subject

Comment*

Verification*


Calendar Search
Event
calendar icon
Zip Code Proximity
of
Entertainment and lifestyle news for Maui, Hawaii and the surrounding Islands. Maui Time Weekly is Mauis only independent and locally owned newspaper. Mail this link to a friend
Web Analytics