SHARE
flag
the grid

Maui County


All downhill from here


Should Haleakala bike tours pedal forward or hit the brakes?



MauiCoNews
shadow
"You don't need to be Lance Armstrong, but you do need to be confident on a bike." --Maui Sun Riders owner Paolo Baricchi
July 24, 2008
In an attempt to gain public input and to get an accurate picture of the downhill bike tour industry on Maui, county contractor Kimura International held a public meeting at Makawao Elementary School Monday evening. About a dozen people showed up to offer various takes on the operation of Halealaka downhill tour companies, expressing concerns ranging from rider safety to traffic.

Thousands of Valley Isle visitors book these tours each year. They involve riding down the road that leads to the Haleakala Summit, a road that descends to sea level more rapidly than any other on the planet. The ride is really more of a glide, and winds down the volcano through virtual moonscapes and cow pastures alike. And, to the chagrin of some Upcountry residents, a few sites laden with local traffic.

Suggestions gathered Monday as well as at a meeting held the following evening in Kula will figure heavily into Kimura’s assessment of the industry on Maui and the recommendations it passes on to the county.

“I foresee some kind of regulation,” said Maui County Councilman Michael Molina, speaking on county actions that would likely result from the study.

The county ordered the $250,000 study on the heels of the National Park Service’s decision to bar tours from operating in the park. That decision was in response to the death of a rider in the fall of 2007 within the boundaries of Haleakala National Park. The study began in May of this year, and its results will likely not be seen until April 2009.

Attendees ranged from tour company owners to vocal community activists who complained that some companies aren’t as stringent about safety and obeying traffic laws as they ought to be. Despite past contention, the meeting hit few snags.

Many in attendance agreed that the bulk of the problems result more from the conduct of certain companies than industry-wide practices.

Phil Feliciano, owner of Cruiser Phil’s, said that regulating the industry is key. A county ordinance setting strict guidelines that standardize rider qualifications, accident reporting and other tour company practices would boost the industry as a whole. Riders on Feliciano’s group tours get an extensive, illustrated safety briefing before embarking downward, and he says he requires his guides to be certified first responders.

Paolo Baricchi, who owns the self-guided tour company Maui Sun Riders, said that physical fitness requirements for riders are vital in the fight to reduce rider injuries on Haleakala.

“It’s not a place where you want to re-learn riding a bike,” he said. “You don’t need to be Lance Armstrong, but you do need to be confident on a bike.”

Part of the discussion revolved around physical improvements to the roadway that might ease some of the traffic strains, given the road’s at times skimpy shoulder and sporadic pullout spots.

Yet some attendees, including Downhill Bike Safety Committee co-founder Mike Perry, questioned the use of taxpayer money for projects that would benefit commercial operations rather than the general public. Perry suggested a $10 per rider tax that would go toward physical improvements and county enforcement of industry-related guidelines.

“If the businesses are going to use it, they should have to pay for it,” Molina said, adding that there has been talk of an industry-wide $1 per rider tax in the past. But $10, he said, “might be a little rough on the industry.”

Kimura will hold a second set of public meetings in October to gain further input. The contractor expects to complete its study of the downhill bike tour industry in January 2009. MTW

print
Print
email
Email Link
Comment
Feedback
share
Share
  1. print email
    Ban It Already!
    July 25, 2008 | 04:12 PM

    I'd like to see the County "man up" and ban this so-called "industry". The owners know nothing about cycling, their bikes are rusty and in terrible condition, they are sucking up our tax dollars for road improvements exclusively for their own use, and the continuous parade of crashes and injuries tie up police and emergency services. Not to mention all the unfortunate people who have to sit there in the traffic jams they cause by driving their vans in the middle of the road at 10 MPH.

    If the County won't ban this farce, how about a requirement that all owners and ride leaders must ride one of those crappy bikes UP the volcano, from Paia to the summit, for every tour they bring DOWN? That should keep the numbers down (to zero!)

    Mr. Uphill
  2. print email
    ridiculous....
    August 03, 2008 | 08:24 PM

    Why not simply 'suggest' that each bike tour have a one hour stop-over in Makawao so the tourists can shop?
    I think that approximately 500 additional 'walking tourists' (in Makawao) a week would add significantly to the economy.
    The main issue, currently with the bike tours, is because of impatient drivers who ignore the posted speed limit.
    Where is the 'aloha spirit'? Gone to Haole-wood?
    'Tourists' = 'revenue' ... where in the world is the Makawao Business Association?

    John Charles Webb, Jr. Makawao Resident
  3. print email
    re: revenue
    August 05, 2008 | 02:05 AM

    Mr. Webb - With due respect, both of your comments are 100% contrary to the facts. (1) The Makawao Biz Assoc is one of the strongest political forces AGAINST the downhills. The tours clog up traffic on Baldwin Ave all day, to the point where customers can't get in there to purchase goods at the stores. Makawao has terrible traffic problems anyway, consequently, the businesses do not want the tours there. (2) The tours average < 15 mph. The speed limit varies between 25 and 40 on that route. Furthermore, the law states clearly that bikes must stay as far over to the right as possible and allow traffic to pass, whereas the written instructions many of the tour cos give their riders instructs them to ride right smack in the middle of the traffic lane at all times. Then there's the matter of the vans blocking traffic, sometimes being used as offensive weapons due to poor training, lack of certification, and lack of drug / alcohol testing of the drivers.

    I'm sure we'd all enjoy a scenic stroll down the middle of Baldwin Ave, from Makawao to Paia, while somebody drives behind in a van at walking speed, blocking traffic. But that's against the law. The "main issue", as you put it, is the vans and the riders do not obey laws already on the books, and the MPD does not adequately enforce them.

    TMSTMS
Reader Feedback Submission
Use this form to submit Reader Feedback.
* required value
Your Name*

Town

Email (not shown on website)

Subject

Comment*

Verification*


Calendar Search
Event
calendar icon
Zip Code Proximity
of
Entertainment and lifestyle news for Maui, Hawaii and the surrounding Islands. Maui Time Weekly is Mauis only independent and locally owned newspaper. Mail this link to a friend
Web Analytics