SHARE
flag
the grid

The Throwdowns


Going Up With a New album and a growing fanbase, The Throwdowns aim high


13.10.Cover.USE

August 27, 2009
Will somebody please get a hold of Spence Jah—he keeps saying 'E. Smith and The Throwdowns'," drummer Ian Hollingsworth reads aloud from his iPhone. His face flushed, shoulders shaking with eruptive laugher, he leans over to show guitarist Ola Shaw the text message he's just received from bassist Kimo Clark (who's out playing softball on the West side).

Grinning, Hollingsworth clenches his fists and mimes mashing them into the table. "It's The Throwdowns!"

"I bet Shaggy put him up to it," says Erin Smith, laughing along.

The band formerly known as Erin Smith and The Throwdowns wisely whittled their name last year. But—as they prepare to drop their first album—they're still fighting to get people to recognize the change. Granted, as Smith suspects, some of it may be the intentional, lighthearted needling from those who know it's one of the group's touchiest topics. They're still all smiles when the subject arises—as they are with most subjects. But seriously, don't call them Erin Smith and The Throwdowns.

With the heavy exposure Smith, a Toronto native, has gotten since she hit the Maui scene, it's no wonder the misnomer lingers. I'm sitting with the band (sadly sans Clark, whose missing energy is notable) at the South Shore Tiki Lounge, at a table set up in the very spot Smith gigs solo weekly. Her acoustic work garners a healthy following, enough to "pay my bills," Smith says. 

"She's like our spokesperson," says Clark in a later phone interview. "One of the things she does really well is talk to people. She's really professional."

I first meet Smith at Requests in Wailuku. She was out working her band beat, hitting the streets with a pile of posters and a stack of tickets, promoting The Throwdowns' big August 28 release party for their debut effort, Don't Slow Down, at Mulligan's on the Blue. 

Smith enthusiastically chatted up the guys at Requests and was mindful to include me in the conversation, which I found pleasant, as I'd made no mention of my role as reporter. In a place that's often uncomfortably sauna-like, she's literally kept her Canadian cool: dressed in grayish periwinkle ensemble, her hair done up enviably in chic frizzle-free curls. Even when we parted, hugging local-style, she was chill to the touch—something I would later notice to be a strangely perpetual state, even after a raucous practice session.

The attention heaped on Smith is by no means undeserved. She's a vivacious go-getter who packs stiletto high-class into her fiery frontwoman kick. You really can't blame those drawn in by her magnetism. Already, I'm guilty of it myself.

But there is a downside: the rest of the band is often relegated to second-fiddle status, given little more than an obligatory nod. Because of this, I was ill prepared for the complete package that is The Throwdowns. By the second song of their practice session during my first evening spent with them, it was resoundingly clear that this band is anything but the Erin Smith show. 

Each member is well-schooled and well-practiced, each plays beautifully to their individual strengths and each engages in a marvelously open, collaborative manner. "We really believe in each other, that's what makes it all run," says Smith.

At first, I found their perpetual positivity to be formulaic and even a tad insipid. They seem to shy away from speaking about themselves and instead prefer to tout the talents of one another, and everything—everything—is "cool." It just didn't seem reasonable that a rock outfit, even one aspiring to edge-maintaining accessibility, could be so genuinely positive and willingly unselfish.

But I quickly discovered that their love—and yeah, I'll call it love—for one another is legitimate. Hollingsworth is the most buoyant in his proclamations of adoration for his bandmates. "I'm in the band of my dreams!" he says in a Facebook post made after their gig at The Gap at the Shops at Wailea (which earned their single, "Kihei Town," some national exposure).

But who cares if they like, let alone love, each other? They've gotta be good, right? 

There's no doubt that the band has some haters. Their win at last year's X 92.5 Battle of the Bands, a four-round showdown culminating in a "battle royale" held at the Hard Rock Cafe, ignited some backlash. 

But upon closer inspection, the hate is hollow—mostly sour grapes from those with vested interest, or whose masculinity seems challenged by a girl with guts and grit (from Canada, no less), or from those who are disappointed by the rock scene on Maui, and insist on comparing it to the homes they left rather than appreciating what it does have to offer and participating in its growth.

It's also worth noting that The Throwdowns have come a long way in the last year. Their early efforts showed talent, spunk and promise, but they were undeniably raw and rough around the edges.

Enter the band's newest member, and missing ingredient: all instrument-wielding Shaw. Shaw, Clark's brother-in-law, was initially brought on board to mix a few tracks. But after catching Throwdown fever, with a little persuading from Clark, he returned to Maui to complete the foursome they now seem destined to have become. Born on Maui, but raised a Big Island boy, Shaw spent seven years in California, where he attended the prestigious Musicians Institute College of Contemporary Music. "Not many people get into there," beams Clark.

As for Clark? "School of hard knocks!" he yelps in his too-cool, effervescently joyful timbre that stands in contrast to his tough-guy, tattooed exterior.

The technical training Shaw brings to the table provides the polish that The Throwdowns needed; he seems to draw out the best in everyone, and catapults the band to a whole new level. At their practice session—a non-stop workout that lasts several hoursemerges as the relentless musical director. He winces when they miss something that to the untrained ear is almost unnoticeable; he halts the train when he feels a change needs be made; he beams the brightest when they hit their mark and hit it hard. 

In the studio—an almost church-like place where they recorded Don't Slow Down and have the luxury of practicing thanks to studio owner Pete Lago—they're working on a track called "Shake Your Bones," which has never been heard outside the band and their 'ohana.

"You're like the first person to hear this!" says Hollingsworth, eager and glowing. His regularly appearing, toothy grin reminds me of actor Ed Helms; I'm instantly smitten by his infectious passion.

Later that week, The Throwdowns are playing Center Stage at Queen Kaahumanu Center thanks to Hot Topic's nationwide showcase, Local Static. It's Friday night, the mall is hopping and a more than healthy crowd has gathered. The upper level on both sides of the stage is packed with curious spectators, and the band gives loving shout-outs to the folks upstairs. The folding chairs aren't nearly plentiful enough to accommodate the turnout; for most onlookers it's standing room only. 

"World premier! Right here on Maui!" Clark shouts with double fists in the air, as they kick off with "Shake Your Bones." 

The crowd is all about it. A group of teenage girls runs up to the stage to rock out for nearly the entire hour-long set, even making up a little hand jive to "Kihei Town," which is currently racing up local charts.

"Thanks for making a 'Kihei Town' dance, girls," says Smith, who has a knack for eye contact and creating audience rapport. 

Afterwards, Smith and Clark head up to Hot Topic while Hollingsworth and Shaw break down the onstage setup. They sign autographs, hawk a few shirts and, most importantly, sell tickets to the release party. Plaid-clad youth with purple hair and chain jewelry throng the store, some with their parents, all wanting to express how "awesome, really awesome," they think The Throwdowns are.

"We try to do the smart guy thing," says Smith, back at our sit-down at the Tiki Lounge. The Throwdowns know that kids buy music, and that building a young following is huge. In keeping with this, they've made their release party an all-ages event, a feat Smith says required "pull[ing] some strings." They're also hip to the technological age—the album is available on iTunes August 29. 

The Throwdowns are a band that's endured its share of criticism, playing in a small, under-the-radar rock scene. Yet their goals are lofty: they want to be famous; they want to be the first multi-platinum band from Maui; they want to tour internationally, to fill stadiums. And—though nothing in life, and certainly nothing in showbiz, is guaranteed—they've got a shot.

But the best thing about The Throwdowns is how easy it is to root for them. Their good nature is no act; once you get used to it, it's incredibly refreshing. They've found the right parts, they've honed their style and they're dedicated to constant evolution. 

Now, if folks would just get their name right. MTW

To share or save this article, type: mt.smub.it/lede6

print
Print
email
Email Link
Comment
Feedback
share
Share

Tags: The Throwdowns

  1. print email
    Das Tulips
    August 28, 2009 | 02:58 PM

    You've got to be fuckin' kidding me! This shit band won a Battle of the Bands? We're deaf fucks judging the show? Maybe Lee Harvey Oswald will make an appearance tonight at the gig.

    Willie Nelson
  2. print email
    OH YEAH!!!!
    August 28, 2009 | 03:34 PM

    ....i second that Willie.....how did that garbage win a battle of the bands?

    Haiku Town
  3. print email
    Too low to grow
    August 28, 2009 | 07:37 PM

    Funny how this jerks' illiteracy makes this a more telling post: "We're the deaf fucks" actually means "we are the deaf fucks"! That is too hilarious! And, of course every band worth it has its' bunch of lowlifes that enhance the cachet of its' sound , but those idiots are way too low for anyone. Please, lose the negativity, and support one of our local bands!

    Surfrsue
  4. print email
    OOOPS
    August 28, 2009 | 07:40 PM

    Lose the "the" in the first "we're deaf fucks" but it still works, you idiots!

    Sue
  5. print email
    Willie & Sue-Bee
    August 28, 2009 | 10:50 PM

    Willie,I agree that this was a pretty weak winner for a battle of the bands.I was there that night and it was quite obvious the judges were very biased(could even call the judges Erin's friends).BTW,it is 'were' bro,but I got your point unlike some people that talk about others negativity but are so self-righteous to not see their own negative thoughts towards someone by way of ridicule.Sue,lose the hat,it don't fit ya.Sue,the aloha spirit you claim to have comes out quite well on your last 2 posts.Stop the charade and realize you're just as bad as Willie when it comes to being negative.

    Arbitrator Neil
  6. print email
    Lets throwdown
    August 29, 2009 | 07:25 AM

    Erin's all right for what she does, but Rock? I don't think so...Ho in the world this band was thought to be suitable to open for 311 or NOFX is beyond me. This is why the Rock scene on the island is so poor, because local media hypes up this junk and passes it off as "grit and guts."

    Train Robber
  7. print email
    You Guys have no idea
    August 29, 2009 | 06:09 PM

    If you haven't seen The Throwdowns in the last 4 months, then you have no idea what you're talking about.

    Plus, the battle of the bands was last year and is so old news.

    Go check out The Throwdowns album on itunes and get yourself up to date.

    Plus - you are all just making yourselves look dumb. Anuhea Yagi wrote off haters such as yourselves in the article and you are embarassed. As you should be.

    Every band that was in the battle is wowed by these guys in their new incarnation.

    Erin is solid as hell. Ola produces, kills it on guitar, Kimo is like a new-school flea and Ian is out of control.

    Get over yourselves. Get off you computer and go to a show.

    Michael
  8. print email
    Hahah haters
    August 29, 2009 | 06:14 PM

    You guys are hilarious.

    You're basically proving the writer's point with your garbage.

    So funny.

    Anyone who was not at Mulligan's last night missed something huge. But I understand it's hard to go out and see for yourselves, when you're busy bitching anonymously on the internet.

    Basing your opinion on Erin's acoustic shows (though she kills), or one show over a year ago does not mean you know anything about The Throwdowns.

    Go check 'em.

    PS - Oahu went wild with The Throwdowns performance with NOFX over there and the NOFX guys love them.

    Amber
  9. print email
    Last night was INCREDIBLE!!
    August 29, 2009 | 06:25 PM

    I have no idea what anyone of you negative folks are talking about.

    I attended The Throwdowns' CD release party last night, knowing nothing about the band. And I was completely blown away.

    Erin is like a Hayley Williams/Gwen Stefani type with a more interesting voice and more of an indie-rock cool.
    The other three band members are hugely entertaining, and all of them have a great rapport with each other onstage.

    I haven't been able to stop listening to the album all day.

    I almost feel like we aren't talking about the same band, with the all the griping I'm reading here.

    Well!
    Your loss. You're missing out on the best band around!


    Joshua G.
  10. print email
    Did you know
    August 29, 2009 | 06:27 PM

    That there were 750 screaming fans at The Throwdowns show last night?

    Hmmm.
    Sounds like it must have been a pretty good rock show.

    David Coburg
  11. print email
    To Be Honest
    August 29, 2009 | 08:02 PM

    I was at the show last night and it was a great turnout.Today,I listened to the cd and was waiting for the WOW factor.It never came for me.Although each song has a distinct sound,it still all sounds like something I've heard somewhere else...and not on Maui.One last thought,I would have to say that Erin needs a vocal coach to help carry some key notes of certain areas of her music.They are rough but with time and practice,who knows?

    Kava
  12. print email
    To Be Honest
    August 29, 2009 | 08:02 PM

    I was at the show last night and it was a great turnout.Today,I listened to the cd and was waiting for the WOW factor.It never came for me.Although each song has a distinct sound,it still all sounds like something I've heard somewhere else...and not on Maui.One last thought,I would have to say that Erin needs a vocal coach to help carry some key notes of certain areas of her music.They are rough but with time and practice,who knows?

    Kava
  13. print email
    My opinion
    August 29, 2009 | 08:53 PM

    The Throwdowns? More like the throwups!

    Not impressed at all. They really have nothing new to offer, and what they do offer has been done better.

    As for having a successful show last night? I'm sure it was a party...I mean Anuhea or Willie K themselves can sell 800 tickets on their own.

    Henry
  14. print email
    Someone Needs To Say It (and stop it with the posing already)
    August 29, 2009 | 09:06 PM

    Is anyone else sick of this over hyped-over-promoted Maui band? Jesus Christ, how is a band that won a battle of the bands that was obviously fixed (by the way they didn't deserve to get out of the first round of that competition because a little band out of Kihei made up of high school kids called Quick Day Scout busted Erin Smith's ass that nite and deserved to win that nite, but luckily Erin had her friends judging. And in the finals Byron or that other young band with the singer who jumped around should've of won but that's for another day) getting so much recognition for being some great transcending band that is just gonna be stuck on this island for the rest of thier lives. The honest truth of the matter is that they're all too old and do nothing spectacular or special to ever warrant any real national recognition. Do you numbskulls know that if you went to any real rock scene in the U.S. whether it be Seattle, Portland, L.A., San Diego, you'd find countless number of bands fronted by a "cute girl in heels" that is way hotter and way more talented than Erin Smith. I mean, "Kihei Town" why are people enjoying this mess of a song. Such great depth and creativity, writing a song about some bozo in a pair of surf shorts and slippers stumblin' around the Triange in Kihei (lol). This sh*t just seems great because you Maui folk have nothing else to compare it to.

    And here's another thing, in the last year we've heard this band be talked about as a "punk" band (lol) and "rock" band (raucous laughter once again) and now reggae (which is good, stick to that genre because the throwdowns music is an insult to rock). Their freakin' show was sponsored by Q103, now i don't know much about the radio but isn't Q103 just some crappy hawaiian, island, reggae station. So how can they call themselves a rock band. Just stop it with the posing already.....a gig at the mall for Hot Topic and a gig at the Gap at the shops of wailea. As far as I'm concerned any music associated with the mall and the gap is not "punk", sorry folks, it just ain't. C'mon people, this crap is softer than Chardonnay. Wake up, open your eyes, cotton swap those ears. I think the sand build up from stumblin' around at the beach all day on the south side is effecting your ability to "listen" to good music......Now that someone has said, chew on that!!!!

    Valkyrie Missile
  15. print email
    You Ain't Putting Up a Fight
    August 29, 2009 | 10:59 PM

    I for once am stunned and lost for words to express my opinion on these haters.

    Seems a lot of people agree your assessments except the Fans, Radio, Industry and Peers. That's OK, (insert cowardly insult here)

    I really don't know where to begin, but I'll do my best to at least point out a few things mentioned above and elsewhere lately.

    **"The battle of the bands was rigged by their friends"....No, the voting was based on audience response. Were you there? and yes, "that was so last year"

    **Arguing whether they shouldn't be classified as 'Rock' is a point well taken. Am I to assume they are amazing if you classify them as 'Pop''?

    **All the crap about the quality and ability of her voice is non-sense. Have you heard Anthony Kiedis of the Chilli's, Perry Ferrell of Jane's Addiction, Steven Tyler of Aerosmith, Bradley Nowell of Sublime, the dude from Nickelback, Kurt Cobain, Billy Corgan of Smashing Pumpkins, KISS etc. Live? They suck-ass live, bordering on tone-deafness. I don't wanna hear it. Vocally they are light years ahead those people. Besides, since when did singing in key become 'rock star'?

    **Someone said Anuhea could draw 800 people also. You know she performed at the show also right? That's all I'm gonna say unless someone else wants to write their opinion of her performance. She didn't even stick around to socialize or watch the Throwdowns. Her tweet 4 hours later said, "Last night at Throwdowns thing was ridiculous."

    **And one last thing, do some research on Ola Shaw of the Throwdowns. No, really look him up, he's already accomplished what many of you say the Throwdowns won't do.

    Thank you for reading and also hating on the bands I play in past and present.

    Shawn Michael, Bass Player
  16. print email
    Shawn Michael
    August 30, 2009 | 08:43 AM

    The battle of the bands was rigged,hate to burst your bubble on that one.I was friends with Jo-Jo(the old 92.5 DJ) and he said it was setup for her to win.You keep missing the point,they are not rock or anything like the bands you have mentioned.Those bands, I would say if those are the bands you have seen live,you are the typical MTV pussy.With the exception of Kiss and Aerosmith and even the Peppers,those bands are a fucking joke that MTV made.I must say you have some weak taste.Her vocal style is way off from those artists.Don't be mad or upset with folks that have an opinion on a group that is justified.Maybe you still have angst that your meal ticket outta here in Vince didn't pan out.The other thing about this Throwup band,they played SXSW this year which is basically a showcase for the A&R fucks...funny to see the Throwups playing Cool Cat Cafe and then Ala Moana Center.Wow,they get center stage at a fuckin mall.Dude,if you follow people's twitter,that explains all I need to know about you.Besides you being a loyal friend to this group and being blinded by this,that still don't change the fact that I feel you are a good bass player.I think we could both agree that her songwriting is quite juvenile.

    James
  17. print email
    Points taken
    August 30, 2009 | 08:50 AM

    I agree, Ola Shaw is amazing...Way to good for this band IMO. I think what the previous poster was implying was that Anuhea could draw a big crowd by herself, and whos to say that moat of the 750 the other night didn't come to see her.

    Some artists don't have pretty voices, in fact a lot of them that's what makes them who they are (billy corgan especially). But a couple things, Steven Tyler is an incredible vocalist, anyone who doesn't think so may want to get there ears checked. And second, where are the girls in that list? I know its a double standard, but to make it in the biz a woman has to have a pretty voice to go with a pretty face...as for the latter, Erin Smith may be about 15 years past her prime to jump into that scene.

    As for the bands genre, here's the thing....They don't have one. They play into whatever crowd is listening. Its almost like an identity crisis, but anyone that has Anuhea as one of there supporters probably is aimed more towards island music rather than rock...or at least what the rest of America thinks Rock is. I'd put her in a Pop/Island music genre, being average in both of those areas.

    I remember Battle of the Bands myself. I can't say if it was rigged or not, but all I remember was wondering why these bands were put together in a battle hosted by x925. Byron rocks, highly Unlikely, I don't see how they can be anything but Rock, Silky Ringo is rock n roll. Erin Smith and the Throwdowns...eh not so much. On air X925 has played all of those bands including a few others from the early round (White Rose, Severed Edges) but they refused to play E. Smith and Throwdowns...why do you think that is? because they didn't fit! But somehow they won that stations Battle of the Bands.

    I don't care for the Throwdowns either way. I personally wouldn't buy their album, but would listen to them while having a few drinks. Then moveon to the next bar act. She has some success on this island, but I doubt they would have much success elsewhere. Live it up Throwdowns. You are in the spotlight for now, but Erin Smith isn't getting any younger and her boobs are only getting lower. Its good to aim high, but multi platinum? Selling out Stadiums? I dunno.

    Not Hater, Just a music fan.
  18. print email
    It's about time
    August 30, 2009 | 09:45 AM

    it's about time people start saying what needed to be said about this group of posers that are trying to front as a "rock" band.

    Finally
  19. print email
    New School Flea?
    August 30, 2009 | 09:53 AM

    are you joking Micheal? you're trying to compare an accomplished musician like Flea to Kimo. What a joke.

    Sure
  20. print email
    Why...You....Point your Judgement on me
    August 30, 2009 | 11:30 AM

    Great to hear the discussion people. I am amazed at the things you quoted me as saying that weren't in my post. Such as the music I like and rating musicians abilities.

    I've been doing this long enough to know that someone is always better and talent has little to do with success as a band/artist. Certainly I would never call someones artistic expression crap. I particularly like the 'meal ticket' comment considering I left the band "Meal Ticket" when they were forming. I wasn't into the whole SoCal ska thing at the time when living in Los Angeles (before NoDoubt and Sublime). Boy was I wrong, my loss, could've toured America and played Lolapalooza with Meal Ticket. Damn, could've been my meal ticket 'out of here' from this awesome place and satisfied life I lead.

    Enjoy the vibes from your judgemental point of view.

    Shawn Michael, bass player
  21. print email
    Lots of Falsehoods
    August 30, 2009 | 05:50 PM

    Hey!
    Lots of falsehoods here.
    Have your opinion, no prob.
    But here's the deal:

    1. The Throwdowns did not play at sxsw this year. That was Anuhea and A Kettle Prime.

    2. Anuhea DID stick around after her set, and I saw her and Erin laughing and talking story.

    3. Erin is the coolest person around. She's not manipulative, she's really chill. She would have no interest in fixing a battle of the bands. She has better things to do. That is all opinion as well, but anyone who has ever spoken to her would know that it is crazy talk. They would also know that she thinks the other bands involved were awesome and would love to see them all kill it.

    4. Jojo asked The Throwdowns to play in the battle of the bands. He also had them on his show several times after the fact and played their songs all the time. So whomever is saying Jojo didn't support them is incorrect.
    I also believe that Jojo saying the battle was fixed is a flat out lie. Why on earth would a person organizing a battle of the bands say such a thing to someone who can't keep their pie-hole shut and is going to post it on the internet?

    5. Anuhea and The Throwdowns have about the same drawing power. I don't believe there has been a show on Maui, headlined by Anuhea, where the crowd was 800 people. But no matter, she's very talented.

    It's all good guys.

    Jordan R.
  22. print email
    People love 'em both
    August 30, 2009 | 05:59 PM

    Implying that the bulk of the crowd was there to see Anuhea is ill-informed.

    Anuhea sounded great! People applauded.
    The Throwdowns hit the stage and the place errupted in screaming. The energy was through the roof.

    You know, it's good to be a music fan and have your opinion.
    The Throwdowns are good guys/gal.
    They're not saying they are better than anyone else. They are just confident. How else does anyone intend to succeed in this world?
    Love what you do and be confident.

    Tony
  23. print email
    Just some thoughts
    August 30, 2009 | 06:04 PM

    This battle of the bands talk is so old. Wow.
    You know it's good The Throwdowns are shaking things up on this island when people are still talking about the boring ol' battle.

    BORING.

    Mostly it was cover bands anyways.

    I don't think The Throwdowns care too much whether they are pop/rock/ska or what have you. They are honing their sound and getting very good.

    Ola joined the band because he's in love with Erin's voice and songwriting. So, if you think he's above them, he is totally for them.

    I feel stupid even writing here because so much of what's been written is just garbage.

    Go Throwdowns!
    If you make it big, great. Maui will support you.
    If you decide you'd rather hang at the beach with us, great! We'll enjoy seeing you there.

    Another music fan
  24. print email
    Stolen Car & E Komo Mai
    August 30, 2009 | 06:09 PM

    I recommend going to itunes to check out "Stolen Car" & "E Komo Mai" from their album. Killer songs!

    Malia
  25. print email
    All the Answers
    August 30, 2009 | 06:10 PM

    I like All the Answers the best!

    Kyle
  26. print email
    Kihei and West Side Clowns
    August 30, 2009 | 08:38 PM

    First of all, this Battle of the Bands business is very relevant because it was the first stepping stone that any local act could've used to get their band to a bigger audience, which the Throwdowns are now doing. So it is very not boring. Ask some of the artists in the competition who were robbed of their chance of getting thier music out there and off of maui if they think the battle is old and boring. And i hate this notion that people were saying "oh she deserved it, she's been doing it for a long time"....blah, blah, blah, to me that just means if you're in your mid 30's and your still doing this and you haven't made it, you aren't gonna make it and you suck.

    And as for JoJo. Yes he organized it by getting all the bands in there, but I know for a fact that people above him had this competition rigged for Erin Smith to win. Because how else can you explain how some high school kids out played her in the first round, yet the judges still gave it to her.

    And to the imbecile that said the battle had mostly cover bands is completely incorrect. There was one cover band, Silky Ringo. All the rest were originals, as a matter of fact Erin Smith actually played a cover of the Strokes at the Battle and thought no one would notice.

    I was very close to this competititon and they way things were put together points all fingers to the competition being rigged.

    If you were there for all the shows, you know how this S**t went down.

    Awright!
  27. print email
    August 30, 2009 | 10:32 PM

    geez you sound stupid!

    honest person
  28. print email
    my goodness!!
    August 31, 2009 | 09:47 AM

    Ahhhhh muscians...all they're trying to do is make music!! They put their heart and soul into their music, lyrics and performances, we should respect that. It seems like there's this race as to which band from Maui can make it "Big"... When all these poor souls what to do is play music, perform and somehow make our lifes a little happier...

    It's really simple, if you like a band's music go see and support them, if you don't, stay home... The old addage: "If you don't have something nice to say about something or somebody, don't say anything at all"....is a good rule to follow.

    Our island is filled with awesome bands...Not enough room to list them all...That's what makes our island so special, there's something out there for everyone.

    Go, Maui bands, Go Go....Keep your spirits up, MAKE MUSIC, and don't listen to all of this nonsense

    music maker's supporter
  29. print email
    Foolishness.
    August 31, 2009 | 01:57 PM

    I agree with music maker's supporter. Shame on you negative simpletons. Shame indeed. Look within yourselves to find where this negative energy is coming from and fix it at once.

    Positively negative
  30. print email
    don't stop
    August 31, 2009 | 03:36 PM

    i know my opinion really doesn't matter just like everyone else's here but i think so many of these letters are out of perspective. erin, ian, kimo, and ola live in a beautiful place, creating, and being able to make a living out of their creations. Of course there will be haters but that just comes with any sort of art. They are really the ones that make success and happiness that much sweeter. And success doesn't have to include mulitplatinum records or selling out arenas. But it's certainly fun trying isn't it? go, Throwdowns, go! i love you guys!

    anomymouse
  31. print email
    go home haters
    August 31, 2009 | 06:17 PM

    The funny thing about this is that The Throwdowns probably don't even care about any of this....all the negative vibes. I really feel bad for all the haters. Sounds like some of you are a little bitter about the battle of the bands that happened over a year ago. I feel sorry for you guys that are so bent out of shape about this. Bitterness is like eating the poision and expecting the other person to die. I was at the show the other night, and I must say, it was pretty amazing. They have thousands of supporters and I think they would be in the same place they are now regardless if they won the battle or not. In the past few months, their music has evolved to be pretty great in such a short amout of time. They have tons of supporters, local and not. Keep doing what you love Throwdowns!

    Pono
  32. print email
    The Throwdowns
    August 31, 2009 | 06:51 PM

    This is sooo funny! hahah I came to check out the article and loved it! Anu, You are an amazing writer!
    I just have to address a couple of issues.
    1. Erin Smith Is a talented songwriter and singer, neither old nor past her prime.
    2. Kimo and Ian Both kill it at what they do.
    3. Every member of the throwdowns are amazing people. (Get to know them)
    4. Believe me... that little battle of the bands had nothing to do with The Throwdowns success
    5. No matter what you may think Erin Smiths song writing skills are way beyond anything I've ever heard in the islands. (If you want to argue this point show me somthing better)
    6. Sounds to me that we have one or two extremely jealous people posting negativity.. When they should be working on their own music.
    7. I will agree to an extent with the post that said "Today,I listened to the cd and was waiting for the WOW factor.It never came for me.Although each song has a distinct sound,it still all sounds like something I've heard somewhere else...and not on Maui." The Throwdowns are a new band... 5 months old to be exact. We produced a record and played a sold out show in five months... Show me a band you know that can do that. You are all going to feel the wow factor after you hear our next album. Though I take extreem pride in this record...It was just a baby step for the throwdowns.
    8. Ola is not to good for this band he loves it and believes in it!
    9. I like what shawn said. There will always be something or someone better than you. But the ones that succeed are doing it anyways!
    Love and support all music.
    Thats what Its all about

    Ola Shaw
  33. print email
    erin works harder than you(dont hate)
    September 01, 2009 | 08:26 AM

    ola no forget,stay humble,pleny great songwriters come from maui, ask ya homegirl erin,she's been payin her dues along side em all these last 5 years.
    throwdowns rock,but no dis the scene that spawned ya'll.

    respect
  34. print email
    Ola....
    September 01, 2009 | 09:31 AM

    ....Erin Smiths song writing skills are way beyond anything I've ever heard in the islands." bro c'mon. how can you say songs like kihei town and stolen cars are intelligently writen songs. you're better that, c'mon. how can you say that with a straight face.

    Brad
  35. print email
    Throwups
    September 01, 2009 | 10:04 AM

    My bet will be they will still be here and playing the same bars on Maui.

    Bet Me
  36. print email
    Silly comments
    September 01, 2009 | 10:19 AM

    You know; I believe that before you start to write, love or hate maybe you
    should know some background on any of the things that you think you know.
    Do you KNOW the basis behind any of these songs you're dissing? NO. Have you actually listened to the lyrics? They not some fluffy sand,surf and palm tree songs... they are very relevent. Just different then what anybody else out here is singing or writing about.
    As fo being on Maui, doing what you LOVE to do and not stuck in some city on the mainland... surely if she wanted to be... she would be. The Throwdowns love the island and this is home to them.
    From what I know, Erin Smith has been all over Canada and the US. Touring and the likes there of.
    She picked Maui to call her home... just like you. Why aren't YOU on the mainland trying to make it.
    To The Throwdowns....
    See ya at the Grammy's and if not... bbq at house?
    I love you all, keep doing what you're doing. Keep reaching for the stars.
    Rino, Keem, O and Skee you are living the dream. Look out world!
    Thank you for an AMAZING ride so far and a great show on Friday.
    All the best.
    To everybody else;
    Much LOVE AND ALOHA,
    Hope you keep living YOUR dream.
    The world is yours.


    Frankie B.
  37. print email
    Not Listening, Clearly
    September 01, 2009 | 12:08 PM

    Kihei Town is so smartly tongue-in-cheek.
    If you've listened to the lyrics, you would know this.
    It's not a sun, sand and surf song. At all.
    It sounds sunny, but it is not.

    It's dark, smart and well-written.

    Anyways, like it if you like it, don't if ya don't!
    But it sounds like the song is smarter than you are.

    Jonathan D.
  38. print email
    Makes me Laugh...
    September 01, 2009 | 12:19 PM

    ...That someone has said here, to Ola, that the songs aren't good.
    Hmmm...I'm pretty sure I heard a radio interview where Ola said "Stolen Car" is his favorite song on the album.

    And I've also heard him talk about Erin's songwriting in interviews a bunch of times. He clearly thinks it's great. End of story.

    Most people would say he's right. Go ahead and have your opinion, but you can't shake the internal walls with these guys.

    That's what makes them so awesome.

    It's just opinion and jealousy. Hell, I'm jealous of what they have and I love their music! Also, it is of note that if people are talking about it, one way or the other, they are doing something right.



    Joey
  39. print email
    itunes!!! Woot!!
    September 01, 2009 | 12:24 PM

    Talk talk talk. So much of it.

    But heres' the real scoop!
    You can buy The Throwdowns' record on itunes for $6.93!!!

    Get over there at once and stop wasting your time reading this mess of thing!

    Lovin' it.

    Daniella
  40. print email
    Really?
    September 01, 2009 | 12:27 PM

    Are we to assume Brad, that you have written a brilliant opus that is adored by the public?

    Oh no? Oh well.

    Guess I'll have to stick with tuning into The Throwdowns on every radio station, and loving their new, well-produced, super-fun, so above any expectation, album.

    Gabe
  41. print email
    So puking smart
    September 01, 2009 | 12:51 PM

    I love how people here occasionally call them "The Throwups", as though it is a clever way in which to dis them.

    I love even more, how every negative comment on this page comes across as so incredibly dumb.

    Aaaand, I'm out.

    Kawika
  42. print email
    Such cool people
    September 01, 2009 | 12:59 PM

    I really wish everybody knew how cool Erin, Ola, Kimo & Ian are.
    I don't even know them super-well, but if you get a chance to hang out with them you would know this.

    They are just working hard at their craft.

    I have no doubt that they will stay as humble as they are. It's easy to shine whatever light you like on people, but they rise above the negative stuff just by being who they are.

    Keep it up guys! We love the music!

    A kid from Maui
  43. print email
    Children at War
    September 01, 2009 | 01:12 PM

    I feel really badly for all the people on here who have been so depressingly hostile towards a group of really talented musicians who are just trying to be the best at what they do.

    I don't know anything about this battle of the bands that people are griping about, but every person complaining about it being rigged and slamming the Throwdowns just come off as petty and bitter and, frankly, like children who lost a game of dodgeball. You sound like a 4 year old having a tantrum.

    Any of you who complain that they don't fit a genre are a little too conditioned by the record industry. The fact that they can play a variety of different song styles is NOT A BAD THING. It's called VERSATILITY. If I've heard one Red Hot Chili Peppers song (to use an incredibly successful band), I've heard them all, but the Throwdowns can switch it up and make each song solid. I LIKE playing an album and having a mix of styles. Some of their songs sound more "new punk", some of them with a reggae swing, some more pop, but they're all awesome. And that means they have the flexibility to play to a larger variety of audiences and be tapped by a lot of different radio stations. That, if I can make an assumption, most likely comes from a group with a lot of different musical tastes and who like to play around with what sounds good and suits each song for the sake of making GOOD MUSIC. Why stay in the "punk" or "reggae" box when they're so freakin' limiting? Especially when Erin's lyrics are so much more clever than 99% of anything you hear in either of those styles? Why not let a sound from the island scene add to the mix? Why not take advantage of the wide skills base that a well-educated, experienced, and talented band can bring in?

    Judging from their fan page on Facebook, there's a hell of a lot of people from on and off the island who have heard about the music and are snapping up the album of iTunes from all across North America (and one chick from Ireland, apparently), and sorry, but I haven't heard of any other Maui band do that.

    If people are coming away from the gigs, filled with hundreds of screaming and dancing fans, happy and excited, and the album's flying off the e-shelves, then maybe, just maybe, all you sour grapes are totally off the mark.

    You don't have to like the band, but for them to cause some of you to react with such anger has much more to do with you than them. Judging by some of the "old" comments, part of the problem is that some of you must not be old enough to shave.

    G McD
  44. print email
    Throwups...
    September 01, 2009 | 01:24 PM

    Throwups is actually a clever dis. just think about it....The music makes some people want to puke, so throwups. Up is also the opposite of down, so the result insult is set up perfectly.

    Besides the dis, though I'll throw in my two cents.

    The Throwdowns are average. Nothing great, but nothing wrong with what they are doing. They fit the scene well. Good for them. I do have to say though I agree that I can't see them having much success outside of the island. Throw their album in the giant pile that major labels receive every day, and I guarantee its headed for the furnace.

    I hope an act form Maui can do something special and get some national recognition, but you gotta really BLOW people away to make it off the island. And I mean ALL people.

    This controversy goes past this article. Obviously The band is well liked by many, but also disliked by a good amount as well. And really no criticism goes unwarranted. So Throwdowns, my advice is step it up a notch. Make music that people CANNOT deny is quality. If you can convince the "haters" otherwise then I see you having potential to make it.

    Trent Samalz
  45. print email
    Impossible.
    September 01, 2009 | 03:27 PM

    No band could ever please everybody. EVER.

    Are you kidding me? It's art.

    Trying to please everyone is a complete waste of time and energy.
    Just do what you do and do it well.

    That's what The Throwdowns do.




    Greg
  46. print email
    The Throwaways
    September 01, 2009 | 03:29 PM

    Out of curiosity,how many bands with members approaching their 30's or in 'em get signed to a major deal and then go on a worldwide tour?This band has just seen its best turnout.And,like it's been mentioned a few times,the mainland is filled with bands that have a female lead with better arrangements and songs,and they aren't signed either.When the music you play is not unique or sets you out far from the crowd,your chances of making it are slim to none.

    To prove that last point,just look at Vince Esquire,he has done some touring and festivals.But how many covers by SRV can you do until your act gets stale.That guy has all the talent in the world,but it would be great to hear more of his stuff than another cover.IMO,Vince is the most talented guy in Maui,maybe I'm biased because I enjoy good music,but he shorts himself with playing the dive bars that require him to play covers instead of his originals.Erin Smith plays her originals but it's just so bubblegum.There's no spark there to say this band is on to something musically.I had read somewhere where they got equated to The Clash as far as being a band that meshes styles together.As a loyal and longtime listener of The Clash,this is insulting.The Clash did meshes quite well and are world renowned for it.The Throwdowns not so well.Paul Simonon had another band after his days with The Clash,Havana 3am,check it out...it's amazing at how well the meshes were done with that band and the latin sounds they incorporated.

    In closing,I really think some of you need to get off island more often and see what the music is like coming out of some other places.Maui is a time warp and it shows through the music that gets played here.The music that most performers create here, sounds dated most of the time.Sorry to say,but Erin Smith stays here long enough she will be another Gina Martinelli,Gail Swanson,Amy Gilliom,and that Anastasia Gillam from Voodoo Suns.I believe they are all lounge singers.

    A Prick
  47. print email
    I love this band!
    September 01, 2009 | 03:31 PM

    Stolen Car is my new fave.

    You gotta get the album!

    Hailee
  48. print email
    To the Prick!!!!!
    September 01, 2009 | 03:40 PM

    Amen brother!!!Keep preachin' and let these clowns know how it is.

    And to all you people who have been stuck on this rock and think that this is good music, get yourself to a record store and buy some real music.

    ...and how dare anyone ever compare the throwdowns to the Clash. What an insult.

    Tom
  49. print email
    Fair
    September 01, 2009 | 03:44 PM

    It's true. Much of the music around here IS dated.

    The Throwdowns are among the few who are working to put a new spin on things.
    I think that's awesome.

    I also think, judging from their immense escalation in the last few months, this is the tip of the iceberg.

    Looking forward to hearing what else they do, no matter the scale.
    Shoots!


    David
  50. print email
    Im The Only one in the band that likes this stuff hahaha
    September 01, 2009 | 07:32 PM

    Negative promotion is still promotion!

    Everyone is going to have there own opinion...... that is what makes the world go round......

    Just to clear things up with my last post.... I wasn't saying that thr is no talented songwriters in hawaii... I actually know and work with tons of them every day.. I am of Hawaiian decent and produce other Hawaiian bands... Hawaii is in my blood and is my roots.... So much talent and culture from here..... But my opinion is still my opinion and I still say Erin Is one of the most talented songwriters I've ever seen on these islands....If that has me loose my street cred here with anyone I can take it :).I personally wouldn't be in the band if I thought otherwise (and cause kimo and ian rock). We are going to continue to write and be good people no matter what negativity comes... We do it because we love music....... This will be my last post... if anyone wants to discuss this further or learn a little about the music business or talk recording E-mail me ola@wearemore.net
    Love and respect to all musicians who spread the aloha with music.

    Ola Shaw We Are More Productions
Reader Feedback Submission
Use this form to submit Reader Feedback.
* required value
Your Name*

Town

Email (not shown on website)

Subject

Comment*

Verification*


Calendar Search
Event
calendar icon
Zip Code Proximity
of
Other Editorial Stories
Arts and Entertainment
The Throwdowns at Mulligans
Saturday (June 26), 8pm, Mulligan’s on the Blue, Wailea, $10 advance / $15 door
Jun 24 2010
“Woo hoo” for The Throwdowns and “nana nana boo boo” to the naysayers. I can’t help but feel utterly ...
Arts and Entertainment
Iration with The Throwdowns at Hard Rock Cafe
Iration Throws Down: Saturday (October 9), 2-3pm (all ages) & 9pm (21+ only), Hard Rock Cafe
Oct 07 2010
The “new roots” rockers of Iration are busy boys. By the spring of this year alone, they supported 47 ...
Columns
Letters
Sep 03 2009
Last week’s feature about The Throwdowns inspired a lot of feedback. Here’s a sampling: ...
Arts & Entertainment
The Throwdowns at Queen Kaahumanu Center and the Gap
Aug 20 2009
The Throwdowns at Queen Kaahumanu Center and the Gap Thursday (Aug. 20), The Gap, Shops at Wailea, 7pm, Free Friday (Aug. 21), Queen Kaahumanu Shopping Center, Kahului, 7pm, Free Celebrating 40 years ...
Business Directories
Best of Maui Arts and Entertainment 2011
The Throwdowns
This BOM award comes on the eve of the band’s first full-length album release (Legs Of Our Own), and ...
Best of Maui Arts & Entertainment 2010
The Throwdowns
They’re the sizzle of Pop Rocks poured over sherbet, sweet and sour firecrackers on a musical mission ...
Entertainment and lifestyle news for Maui, Hawaii and the surrounding Islands. Maui Time Weekly is Mauis only independent and locally owned newspaper. Mail this link to a friend
Web Analytics